Sure.. those items are nice but the Sony cameras just do not produce the same quality of image as the canon's do consistantly. The extra MP is nothing... the LCD is a bit larger but you do not get the fantastic swivel screen which once you start using, you will never want to be without. Obviously, hand feel is quite important.

I would also recommend again the S2 over the S3.. you can get one much cheaper (about $300 used!) if you shop around... a great price for a great camera.. good luck with whatever you choose.